Your Money MattersConsumer Reports


Consumer Reports: Bias vehicle crash testing

Posted at 5:35 AM, Jan 08, 2020
and last updated 2020-01-08 08:32:40-05

TUCSON, Ariz. - You might think that by the looks of this crash test dummy it would represent a wide range of drivers. But despite their blank faces and androgenous features, most dummies used in auto crash tests represent a very specific type of driver: an average adult male, which researchers say pose a safety risk to women.

“There are no crash test dummies that represent the average female in our country, and that’s despite the fact that women are nearly half the drivers and are more than half the population," says Consumer Reports Advocacy Expert, David Friedman.

Results from safety crash tests like this one have a direct impact on how cars are designed to make them safer. But if safety tests prioritize adult men, what does that mean for women? A recent study from the University of Virginia reveals a seat belt-wearing woman is 73% more likely to be seriously injured in a frontal car crash than a man.

“This has been a clear problem since at least the 1980's, back when the regulators actually first asked for there to be dummies starting to represent women," says Friedman. What they got was a scaled-down version of a male dummy that today is so small that really it represents a young teenager.”

Automakers disagree that a change would help. The Auto Alliance, a US automaker trade group, told CR they do not believe a female dummy would be useful because the current American female is closer in height and weight to the male dummy currently used for testing. But Consumer Reports says carmakers and crash testers need to consider much more than just the size of dummies for different genders.

“It’s not enough for us to just take the male dummy and scale it down to the size of a female," says Emily Thomas Ph.D., Consumer Reports Injury Biomechanics. "There are important physiological differences between men and women that makes our bodies react differently during a car crash. That’s why it’s important for us to account for these biomechanical and material differences in our dummy design.”

Government agencies are evaluating a new set of dummies, called THOR. They have been in development since the 1980's and may be used in European crash tests as soon as 2020. They’ll be able to collect more data than the current model. However, there are currently no plans for an average female THOR dummy.