Your Money MattersConsumer Reports


Consumer Reports: Are leafy greens worth the risk?

leafy greens.JPG
Posted at 4:00 AM, Feb 12, 2020
and last updated 2020-02-12 08:49:03-05

TUCSON, Ariz. - If you think you can’t go wrong eating leafy greens, like lettuce, kale and spinach, you’re mostly right. They’ve been linked to reduced risk of heart disease, some cancers and Type II diabetes.

But behind their star-studded benefits lie risks that can be dangerous. Between 2006 and 2019 greens like romaine, spinach, and bags of spring-mix were responsible for at least 46 national outbreaks of E. coli, causing many hospitalizations and even some deaths.

“So here’s the challenge: we want people to eat these green vegetables but they’re easily contaminated by bacteria," says Consumer Reports Chief Scientific Officer, James Dickerson Ph.D.

Bacteria that come from animal feces can get onto the foods we eat. Many greens, especially romaine lettuce, are grown in California and Arizona. For leafy green farmers, keeping fields free from dangerous bacteria is a challenge!

“You’re always worried about contamination from animals," says Farmer, Amber Brouilette. "If you’re growing leafy greens outside even just wild birds flying overhead increases the risk of contamination by salmonella and E.coli.”

It is important for farmers to take steps like keeping animals away from fields, sanitizing equipment and boots, and wearing gloves. But even with these precautions, it’s still possible for contaminants to end up on the greens. So should you stop eating leafy greens? CR says that for most people, the nutritional benefits far outweigh the potential contamination risks.

Not everyone who is exposed to Salmonella or E.coli gets sick, but for people who are most vulnerable. That includes pregnant women, older adults, infants and young children, and anyone with a compromised immune system.

“One of the best things you can do is cook it. So cook it to the point where it’s wilted," says Dickerson.

And Consumer Reports says don’t be fooled by labels saying greens have been tripled washed. Even the most thorough washes are primarily designed to remove dirt and grit, they can't ensure that greens are bacteria-free.